Most Valuable Newsstand Comics From Copper Age

Here is the top 10 most valuable newsstand comics in 9.8 grade that are published during the Copper age.

While newsstand comics are more common in the Copper era relative to the Modern age, getting in 9.8 is still going to be a challenge. Most of them are handled badly by newspaper stands, with lots of spine ticks and creases.

As this 9.8 newsstand market develops, the list below should give you an idea on how much they are worth currently.

Honorable Mention: Uncanny X-Men #221

Date of Publication: 1987
Sale number:
Value: $380

Key strengths of this book
1. First appearance of Mister Sinister

 

X-Men #221 has been slowly creeping in price. I suspect this is due to the new X-Men series which Sinister has been featured almost everywhere.

The average selling price for a regular 9.8 is around $270. In contrast, the newsstand 9.8s have been steadily increasing to $370-$400 range. This represents a newsstand premium of around 30-50%.

10: Batman #428

Date of Publication: 1988
Sale number:
Value: $350

Key strengths of this book
1. The Death of Robin

 

Batman #428 caused quite a sensation when it was first released due to the death of robin. Although the death has since been reversed, collectors still have fond memories of this book.

Sales of the regular versions of this 9.8 is around $270. From this, the newsstand premium is about 30-40%, which is not as significant as others on this list.

9: Amazing Spider-Man #306

Date of Publication: 1988
Sale number:
Value: $390

Key strengths of this book
1. Homage cover to Action Comics #1

 

This book is on this list purely on the strength of its newsstand premium. Although it has a nice homage cover, there is nothing else that makes this book special.

Direct editions of Amazing Spider-Man #306 in 9.8 is selling for $100. This $400 sale is 4X of that price tag. That is how much the buyer is willing to fork out to own a newsstand version of this book in 9.8.

At the supply level, this book in newsstand 9.8 is not commonly on Ebay. You cannot find one for sale at any time, unlike some of the other books on this list.

8: Transformers #79

Date of Publication: 1991
Sale number:
Value: $450

Key strengths of this book
1. Second to last issue; hard to find

 

Tied with number #7 on this is Transformer #79. This is the second to last issue of the series, which has much lower print run than the earlier issues. As a result, 9.8s are harder to come by, especially in newsstand editions.

A similar sale in April of a regular version goes for $150. In comparison, this sale of $450 is about 3X more, which means it has a pretty high newsstand premium.

However sales data for this book in 9.8 is pretty scarce so there might be wild fluctuations in its value. Let see if this book can continue to stay on the list in the next update

7: Marvel Secret Wars #8

Date of Publication: 1984
Sale number:
Value: $450

Key strengths of this book
1. Origin of alien symbiote

 

Talk about popular. The Spider-Man black costume is going to take up this and the next 2 slots of the list!

The 9.8 newsstand edition of Marvel Secret Wars #8 has a moderate premium over its direct editions. The latter is selling for $300 on average while the newsstand usually command 50% more.

Compared to #8, the lower newsstand premium might be due to this book having more newsstand 9.8 available.

6: Amazing Spider-Man #252

Date of Publication: 1984
Sale number:
Value: $600

Key strengths of this book
1. First appearance of black costume

 

While the value might seems high, Spider-Man is actually one of the worst newsstand 9.8 on this list.

One, there is plenty of newsstand 9.8 on Ebay so it is not rare.

Two, because of the above, prices for the newsstands 9.8 is exactly the same as the direct versions.

Hence, Spider-Man #252 is just a particularly valuable book, not because it is a newsstand.

5: Spectacular Spider-Man #101

Date of Publication: 1985
Sale number:
Value: $650

Key strengths of this book
1. Cover art

 

Spectacular Spider-Man #101 doesn’t have any first appearances but its gorgeous black and white cover is all that is needed.

The market has not always recognized the newsstand premium for this book. In March 2020, it was still selling for around the same price as the regular, which is around $350.

In May, prices started to shoot up. The latest sale was in June and ended with a $678 price tag from an auction. Collectors were fighting over this book!

4: G.I.Joe #26

Date of Publication: 1984
Sale number:
Value: $700

Key strengths of this book
1. Origin of Snake Eye

 

The upcoming Snake Eye movie is heating up his books, including this one as well as GI Joe #1 and GI Joe #21.

Using Ebay, it seems that this book does not have many 9.8s available for sale. A newsstand version is even harder to come by, which might explain this high sale number.

The regular version of this book was selling for $140 in Apr but a current auction is already beyond $200. It should settle for between $400-500. In this case, the newsstand version has a premium of around 50-60% over the regular.

3: Hulk #340

Date of Publication: 1988
Sale number:
Value: $800

Key strengths of this book
1. Iconic cover

 

Hulk #340 has one of the most copied covers, losing perhaps to Amazing Spider-Man. This tells you how iconic this cover and why it is able to command such a high price, newsstand or not.

Regular versions have been selling between $600-800. In this case, there isn’t any strong newsstand premium attached to this book. I wonder if that represents an investment opportunity as the market is not recognizing the scarcity of the newsstand version.

2: Uncanny X-Men #266

Date of Publication: 1990
Sale number:
Value: $900

Key strengths of this book
1. First appearance of Gambit

 

With such a high print run, you will have thought that a 9.8 newsstand will be easy to come by. Apparently, it is not as plentiful as one thought. Most of the time, there is 0 or 1 copy of a newsstand 9.8 of this book at Ebay at any one time.

Prices have went up fairly recently. In March/April, the same book was going for $650-680. The current price means it has grown by 30% over a period of 2 months.

In comparison, a regular version of a X-Men #266 9.8 is commanding about $450. This means there is a 100% newsstand premium that we are seeing for this book.

1: New Mutants #98

Date of Publication: 1991
Sale number:
Value: $950

Key strengths of this book
1. First appearance of Deadpool

 

Despite having the highest priced newsstand 9.8 on this list, New Mutants #98 won not because it is a newsstand. It is the highest priced simply because the book itself is the highest priced book in the list.

When you compared the $950 price tag with regular versions, there is actually almost no newsstand premium for this book. In this case, it is similar to Hulk #340 in terms of presenting a good investment opportunity?

Rankings by newsstand premium

The above list was ranked according to absolute values. However, this can create a situation whereby a book is high on the list not because it is a newsstand but because it is a valuable book, like New Mutants #98.

If I re-rank result based on newsstand premium, the list will look as follows:

  1. Amazing Spider-Man #306 – 4X newsstand premium
  2. Transformers #79 – 3X newsstand premium
  3. Uncanny X-Men #266 – 2X newsstand premium
  4. Spectacular Spider-Man #101 – 90% newsstand premium
  5. G.I.Joe #26 – 50-60% newsstand premium
  6. Marvel Secret Wars #8 – 50% newsstand premium
  7. Batman #428 – 30-40% newsstand premium
  8. New Mutants #98 – 10-20% newsstand premium
  9. Hulk #340 – 0% newsstand premium
  10. Amazing Spider-Man #252 – 0% newsstand premium

From the list, it is clear the supply plays a very important role. For comics with the the highest newsstand premium, their supply of newsstand 9.8 is very limited, if you go by the times they got listed on Ebay.

In contrast, books like Amazing Spider-Man #252 have plenty of newsstand 9.8 at any point in time on Ebay.

The only exception is Hulk #340. It doesn’t have that many newsstand 9.8 but there is also no premium. Perhaps the market hasn’t recognize this yet, which means there is a good opportunity to buy a newsstand at the same price as a direct.

The important question is whether the rest of the hard to get newsstand 9.8 will follow the likes of Spider-Man #306 in terms of having a higher premium. If so, we might see some very good returns if we start to hoard them now.

One thought on “Most Valuable Newsstand Comics From Copper Age

  1. Sandman 8 karen berger editorial nott a newstand but copper and impossible to find. Along with Sandman 75 2nd print

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Releated

Most Valuable 2nd Print Comic

This is the first top 10 rankings of the most valuable comics that are 2nd prints, published after 2000. The ranking was inspired by CGC’s top 10 most valuable modern variants. Since 2nd print has become a somewhat popular, the information might be of value to some collectors. The ranking is sorted from the least […]

Hot 30 comics for 2020

Here are the hot comics for 2020 as well as what will be hot for 2021 and beyond. The data comes from a combination of: Ebay sales Hot comics list from different sites CGC forum threads on what is selling It is not a ranking list and might not be exhaustive. Based on these hot […]